evidence-based blog of Filippo Dibari

Two charities challenge company’s patent on Plumpy’Nut

In Under-nutrition on October 18, 2012 at 2:56 pm

by Clare Dyer

from the British Medical Journal (BMJ) 2010;340:c2510

“The US patent for a peanut based food product that has transformed the treatment of acute malnutrition in Africa has come under challenge by two US not for profit organisations that say they could produce similar products more cheaply.

“The California based Mama Cares Foundation and Breedlove Foods in Texas have filed a joint suit in the US District Court in the District of Columbia to try to overturn the patent held by the French company Nutriset.

“Nutriset’s Plumpy’Nut, a blend of peanut butter, powdered milk, vegetable oil, and sugar fortified with vitamins and minerals, is said by some experts to have revolutionised aid agencies’ response to malnutrition and become the standard “ready to use therapeutic food” (RUTF).

“It achieved dramatic results in Niger in 2005. Because it doesn’t need to be mixed with water, children who would previously have to be taken to hospital can be treated much more cheaply at home.

“Nutriset and its partners around the world provide the bulk of the world’s supply, but Mike Mellace, executive director of Mama Cares, said it was poised to ship its rival Re:vive product to Africa, Honduras, South East Asia, and other regions.

“The patent lawyer Robert Chiaviello is giving his services free of charge to the two organisations. Mr Mellace said that their main claim was that the patent should not have been granted because Plumpy’Nut was not novel or unique.

“If you grab a jar of Nutella and compare it to the ingredients statement on Plumpy’Nut you’ll find that it’s virtually identical. All that they’ve done is change the mixture round and have a higher vitamin and mineral mix to get to the proper WHO specifications, which anybody could do.”

“He said that Mama Cares, a non-profit offshoot of his family snack business, had managed to reduce its costs to $0.4 (£0.27; €0.78) a unit; Plumpy’Nut costs 0.55 a unit. “If you simply took the same aid dollars you could treat 30% more children because the product is cheaper.”

“Nutriset has recently started manufacturing Plumpy’Nut in the United States, in partnership with a non-profit body called Edesia. Its network of partner manufacturers also produce Plumpy’Nut locally in Niger, Ethiopia, Malawi, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the Dominican Republic, India, Madagascar, and Mozambique.

“The company, which has registered patents in the European Union, the US, Canada, and 32 other countries, has sent legal letters to other producers of nut based RUTFs. It was criticised in an open letter last November by the international humanitarian organisation Médecins Sans Frontières for sending a letter asserting its intellectual property rights to the Indian and Norwegian manufacturer Compact.

“Adeline Lescanne, deputy general manager of Nutriset, said: “Some may pretend they are able to produce the equivalent of Plumpy’Nut at a cheaper price, but we fear that those solutions may not be [long lasting]. What should be the goal: to have companies manufacturing an RUTF in the North or to have them helping to develop local nutrition capacities, working with local health authorities, transferring competences to the South?

“It’s interesting to see the plaintiffs working on new products. Our patent on Plumpy’Nut gave them motivation to seek something else. What is really needed are increased efforts to prevent malnutrition. There are lots of things to do in the prevention field.”

– – –

NB – To follow up this topic (or others), enter your email in the rectangle at the bottom/right side of this page (you can un-subscribe any time).

  1. I am interested to learn about this subject .

    Like

  2. Thank for ur effort in combating malnutrition especially in Africa. We have made several attempt through Better Care Foundation an NGO for Diarrhea and Malnutrition org to get your plumpy nut registered for commercial distribution in Nigeria but all to no avail.
    My question is, can your plumpynut and other products now be ordered for commercial distribution? My contact mobil num is: +23480 3343 4131
    Thank you.

    Like

    • Dear Mr Rally – thanks for your comment. I do not have the answer – I live in Mozambique.

      You may wish to contact the supply (http://www.nutriset.fr/en) or other organizations which tried to create opportunity for Nigerian production of these foods.

      If the last case is of interest you may wish to contact Valid Nutrition (http://www.validnutrition.org/). The director of Valid is called Steve Collins (steve@validinternational.org). You can mention how you got his contact.

      Let me know if I can be more helpful.

      My best regards and thanks for your comments on the blog.

      fil

      Like

    • Dear Mister Rally, thanks for your contact message and apologies if I reply so late. Did you try to contact Nutriset? Try here: http://www.nutriset.fr/en. Nutriset is the main distributor world wide of plumpynut. Alternatively you can contact Valid Nutrition ( http://www.validnutrition.org/). I hope this can help and sorry again for the late reply. Please, let me know about the follow up. I would love to visit your project in the next trip to India. Best regards. fil

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: